Come in! Come in!

"If you are a dreamer, come in. If you are a dreamer, a wisher, a liar, a Hope-er, a Pray-er, a Magic Bean buyer; if you're a pretender, come sit by my fire. For we have some flax-golden tales to spin. Come in! Come in!" -- Shel Silverstein

Friday, March 27, 2015

Indiana: Newton's Third Law

In case you haven't heard, yesterday, Indiana Governor Mike Pence signed the so-called "religious freedom" bill into law during a private ceremony in his Statehouse office.

This bill purports to protect persons and businesses from government reprisal if their decisions to treat groups of people differently (in the provision of services and goods, for example) stem from what they claim to be religious beliefs – even if those beliefs are not part of the formally professed teaching of any established religious group.

It's a hideous affront to the fundamentals of our Constitution.

Or, as Susan Russell calls it, it's a "Weapon of Mass Discrimination". 

Proponents of the bill say it is not about discrimination.

Of course not.  It's about "religious freedom". See?

So, if someone comes into your store or your bakery or whatever your business happens to be, and you figure out that they are . . . .oh, I don't know, let's say . . . you figure out that they're gay.

AND . . . your religion teaches you that being gay is . . . oh, I don't know, let's say . . .  an "objectively / inherently disordered" condition.

WELL . . . not to worry about having your religious beliefs compromised by having to serve this . . . abomination in the sight of the Lord. Your "religious freedoms" have been protected.

Some of the "Religious Leaders" at the signing of the new law
Or, say, a woman comes into your store or your bakery or whatever your business happens to be, and you can tell, just by looking at that expensive suit she's wearing and that fancy-schmancy jewelry she's sporting, and the conversations she's having on that expensive cell phone that's partially hidden under her perfectly colored and coiffed hair that she's probably not . ..  how shall we say? . . . your typical 'homemaker".

AND . .  your religion teaches you that a woman's place is in the home. With her husband. And, with as many children as our Abundant God deigns to give her.

WELL . .. not to worry about having your religious beliefs compromised by having to serve this . . . this . ..  Woman! Your "religious freedoms" have been protected.

And, let's not even talk about an interracial couple who walks into a restaurant and expects to be served.

No, let's not even talk about that.

Especially if they are wearing garments made of two different materials, or have tattoos, or collect interest on money they have in the bank, or . . . . Well, just read Leviticus.

Or, not. Actually, you don't even have to be following a formally professed belief of any established religion. If your name is Judy and you believe something about God then you are following Judy-ism. Or your name is Brian, you could be a Follower of the Life of Brian. 

As the Episcopal Bishop of Indianapolis, the Rt. Rev'd Catherine M. Waynick, wrote to her diocese:
Consider the possibility that only Christians will be served in some places, only Jews in others, while no Muslims, Buddhists, Zoroastrians, or Druids can purchase merchandise in some stores, and only Latinos will be included here, only Blacks excluded there....you see the point. This legislation gives the appearance of tolerating and protecting overt bigotry in any form so long as it is dressed up as personal religious fervor.
Oh, but wait. That's not the bad news.

The really bad news is that this is just part of the first of a wave of a something Ms. Mouthermouth Maybelle, a character from Hairspray, once called, " . ..  a whole lotta ugly comin' at you from a neverending parade of stupid." 

The truth is that Indiana is the 20th state to pass a Religious Freedom Restoration Act into law.

Let me say that again so it will sink in: Twenty (20!!) states now have a Religious Freedom Restoration Act as a law on their books. 

There are more on the way. Arkansas and Georgia are poised to be next.

As astounding as all of this is, there's a really simple explanation for it all: Physics.

Newton's Third Law, to be specific.

You might remember it from high school physics:
"For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction."
Consider: Marriage Equality will soon be the law of the land.  Thirty-seven states and counting. 

You didn't think it was going to be that easy, did you? I mean, that LGBT people would win our civil rights state by state by bloody state and then, it would all be rainbows, lollipops, roses and sunshine?

Consider: In 2012, this country elected its first Black President for a second term of office.

And yet, despite the Civil Rights Act of 1965, there has been a gradual erosion of voting rights which includes redistricting, gerrymandering, redlining and requiring documented evidence of personhood (which, for these same people, simply being an embryo can prove that). 

Sometimes, the "equal and opposite reaction" isn't always as easy to follow as a straight line.

I'm told by my friends who work in shelters for victims of domestic violence that there has been a sudden increase in women and children seeking assistance over the past six months.

There are lots of factors, of course, but it turns out that when some people - mostly men who are Caucasian / Western European - feel threatened by forces out of their control - like gay people being able to get married or women making more money than they do or transgender people obtaining civil rights - they come home and kick the dog. Or, their wives. And, kids.

On one level, it's pretty pathetic.

On another level, it has ever been thus.

Man on top. Says so in the Bible. Try to change that and expect Newton's Third Law to kick in.

So, the political physics of the situation looks like this: 37 states with marriage equality + 20 states with Religious Freedom Restoration Act = Newton's Third Law. 

Here's the thing: This is such an affront to the very idea of 'liberty' - what generations of men and women in this country have fought and died for - that it is simply a matter of time before these laws are challenged and overturned.

That's also part of Newton's Third Law, sometimes stated as, "What goes around, comes around."

These laws - which are an abomination in the very sight of Jesus - will be challenged and eventually repealed. Of that, I have no doubt. In the meantime, a lot of people will be hurt. And, angry. And, outraged. And, that would be exactly right.

As my blessed grandmother used to say, "Prejudice kills brain cells."

It is important to be outraged. It is more important, as Mother Jones famously said, to "Pray for the dead and fight like hell for the living."

If you aren't convinced to get out and vote in every single bloody election - and help others to get to the polls to cast their ballot - I don't know what will persuade you. 

Maybe remembering Newton's Third Law will do it: "For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. "

As Sinclair Lewis rightly predicted in Babbit:  "When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross."
 
Let this 20th state to pass a Religious Freedom Restoration Act into law be the "tipping point".

Stop the momentum of this growing movement. Push back against injustice and bigotry and fascism masquerading as "religious freedom".

VOTE! And, make sure to help others get to the voting booth, too.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh please.

President Clinton signed the federal version into law two decades ago. It hasn't seemed to stop our black-robed dictators into imposing same-sex marriage on the majority of the states of the Union against the will of the people.

All this bill does is stop lawyers and perverts from seeking to ruin God-fearing Americans with frivolous lawsuits and to (unsuccessfully) prevent governments from encroaching upon religious liberties without having to withstand the test of strict scrutiny.

xyMichael

Elizabeth Kaeton said...

Michael, Michael, Michael. No, President Clinton did NOT sign THAT version into law years ago. The one he signed is an amplification of the Constitution. The Indiana law is quite different. Your education about this law is sadly lacking. Perverts? Well, there it is, then.

Marthe said...

After reading this, I've come back several times to check on the comments and was surprised so few were made, but then the ever trolling Michael checked in .. ah. so not surprising. What these alleged defenders of the faith always miss in their arguments is the simple fact that while they are free to believe as they choose, they are not free to inflict, force or impose their beliefs on others. That they so desperately insist on imposing their version of religion on the rest of us only undermines their understanding of faith & freedom and exposes their real agenda: inflicting "order" on others to guarantee their own privilege ... which means they are so very afraid of the rest of us that any means necessary are okay to keep us out of their nightmare scenarios, namely that they are exposed for the bully frauds that they are and entitled to no more or less the love of God than anyone else. It is sad to see so much energy wasted fussing about other people's lives ... in my world it's considered just icky to fixate on what others do behind closed doors and soooooo none of my business ... consenting adults and all that ... but then, I'm not suffering from any delusions of superiority. Happy Easter to you and all those not closet empire admirers.

Elizabeth Kaeton said...

Marthe - Right. We still live in a democracy. Not a theocracy. I think we should send everyone who wants to impose their religious beliefs on everyone to Syria or Iran. You know, so they get to see what it's really like.

A blessed Easter to you.

howdidIgethere said...

You say "These laws - which are an abomination in the very sight of Jesus - will be challenged and eventually repealed." I fear it may be a long time until "eventually". Until then, these intolerant, hateful people will be protected from legal action by those whose civil rights they deny!

Unfortunately, one must remember that the "black-robed dictators" are the justices of the Supreme Court who decided that there was no longer a need for protections provided by the Voting Rights Act, told us that money was "speech", and insisted that a corporation can have religious beliefs! I fear that, in its current makeup, SCOTUS will continue down the Hobby Lobby path, rather than put limits on the exercise of bigotry in the name of "religious liberty."

Wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross, indeed!

Long-time reader but rare commenter, MAH

Elizabeth Kaeton said...

Eventually. Yes, a bit of a hopeful understatement. I hope you're wrong about SCOTUS, but I fear you may be right.

Richard Yelland said...

Elizabeth. We do live in a republic. When a governor puts forth this preposterous action, it is left to us to remind the voters that it is not beneficial to all. They do have the power to remove that detriment.

Richard Yelland said...

I can only hope that the backlash will get this legislation removed. I would move from a state that imposed that counter activity to good business. I am quite sure that many friends feel the same way as I. Our goal is to treat all humans the same. If you draw air and exist, your rights should be the same as all the rest, no more, no less.